ADR3-N's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Hyper Fern]

I think the new philosophy works for you swimmingly. Nothing stale, new elements added and taken away and nothing jarring about it at all. Some small critiques. at 1:58 or so, that lead isn't sticking out well against the reverbs going on. Some sidechained multiband compression there may help, as well as ducking reverb frequencies below 250 hz.

I personally am not a fan of the snare. I think it could be pitch shifted or warped a bit higher (snares have tonal qualities too, and resonances, and when pitched right, will fit more naturally in place!), or you could clip it more, or alternatively switch it out. Whatever you'd choose, I would also bring it up a little. It is sitting in the mix a bit flat.

Otherwise, love it. Great work! Thanks for coming out to NGADM!

supermelon-creations responds:

Thankss~ in my modern songs I tend to pay a lot more attention to those details, but still you are right, maybe I shouldve made an updated version, but thx for the critique

[The Promise]

My critique for this piece boils down to the occasional articulation that sounds a bit out of place/sharp, or the outtro that is a bit loud. Your use of your sound palette is artful, and your writing is a pleasure. Great work!

I do think the section after 2:36 could be a bit less abrupt and somewhat quieter. Otherwise, slammin score.

Thanks for coming out to NGUAC!

Baumarius responds:

Thanks! I appreciate the critique.

I assume you mean the NGADM? X3

[Death (Horseman) | SynnCloud]

Beautiful shreds. My only complaints, tune those upper bass strings, and perhaps lower. I can't quite tell. Something sounds out of tune when you hit that upper octave, like, real bad on octave jumps as well, sounds sharp by a quarter tone or more. Also, there is a lot of low end reverb wash it sounds like throughout. Hi-passing your reverb if you want a shoegaze always helps clarity.

I'm happy your bass however didn't get lost in the mix. Sounding good tonally.

Your snare very much would benefit from being brought forward in the mix. I have a hard time hearing it.

Otherwise, love the shreddage, great melodic themes, appropriate use of tolling bells. Thanks for coming out to NGADM!

SynnCloud responds:

OMGGG THANK YOU SO MUCH <33, ILL TAKE THE TIP

[I Fly So High | NGADM | Wave | Royalty Free + MIDI |]

This is a nice composition with many unexpected melodic directions on your vocal -- at times I think it could be a bit more on pitch, spot corrected perhaps, or overdubbed for the occasional flub. As this is such a naked piece, your vocals being ON are even more important than ordinarily would be. It's worth investing in a pitch correction/vocoder or something along those lines if you don't have time to do lots of dubs, and perhaps a singing course. I personally recommend Ken Tamplin (and I am no great singer by any means, I feel you!)

The vocal mix is present at the right levels to be heard, but I am really distracted by the heavy low mids on it, and it sounds nasal. That could be from a common cold, OR from recording up close to the mic where your nose is above or past the diaphragm and as such nasal resonance can't be heard.

Besides that, great piece. I appreciated the lyrical themes, and captain plugins definitely came in clutch. Good work!

Thanks for coming out to NGADM!

Aalasteir responds:

Thank you so much, I really appreciate your thoughtful insights into music, you are really knowledgeable and I respect you as a skilled musician.

[3manon - Brainstorm (Mindscapes EP)]

Nice atmospheric beginning. I would say tone down your reverbs early on, at least the low mids, as they are somewhat distorting at 44 seconds and clipping. I don't think that's what you want in a dnb mix, as you want nice crisp breaks.

At 1:05 your writing is smooth and so are your choices in transition. Lovely chords and smooth leads. Very olskool and pleasant, but throughout your bass is overly present in the 200 hz range, owing to what sounds like reverb.

Section at 2:10 has nice melody and harmony. Great.

2:27 switchup and throat singing is a great choice. Keeps things varied. Mix is also sounding a bit cleaner here, but still really present with the reverb.

I would recommend switching out the strings at 3:08, up high, to something like LABS's free library.

3:30 is sounding good coming in on that hi-pass, notice a lot of the low reverb wash is passed out. Nice key change here as well. Overall I really appreciate the themes presented here in your track. Great work.

I think that guitar could use to be switched out with something that has more varied articulations, same as whatever bass that is. You can certainly find the same sort of tonality and keep that variety.

Beyond that, I don't think I have much left to say. Thanks for coming out to NGADM!

3manon responds:

Thank you for your kind words and feedback! Did you know I recorded my own throatsinging btw?

[PartySlaughter (May 2022)]

Sounds a lot like olskool dnb I used to listen to. Nice!

I would pump up the sub on the bass through 40 sec and find a way to stereo widen or chorus the frequencies on it above 500 hz. It's a very organic sound and I really enjoy it but I feel it needs more intensity, more saturation, clipping, something. Otherwise. I enjoy the acid vibes at 1:40 very much.

This track is both relaxing, vibrant, and dynamic. Very much enjoy that.

For the section at 2:18 I would bring down the reverb on your saws and the saws themselves somewhat. Or alternatively you can really pump the kick and snare. But it seems hi-hat and all may be getting buried there by reverb wash.

It does not sound like this has any mastering compression, which it would benefit from. There are several online mastering services, even some for free, which would help in this regard, but I would recommend revisiting to mix prior to attempting that.

Overall, really enjoyed the track. Familiar and comforting in the sense I love the genre, and fresh in the sense it's not 20 years old xD

Thanks for coming out to NGADM!

TheNormalMusic responds:

Woah, that's a long one...
Yeah, it's based a lot on those early 00's tracks, I really like their vibe too. Mastering and stuff like that is not made well, I couldn't make it better back in the days, when I was making this song. Anyway, thank you for that review and that you like this song!

[Pooo1-Summer wave]

Interesting blend of sounds and offbeat feel (also I like your icon)

I'm not really able to offer much critique beyond I think your drop could use an offbeat bass to hold down the bottom of the track, an octave lower than your top bass, and perhaps a side chain to the kick and snare for any instruments holding long tones there would help as well. There is not a lot of contrast to help delineate where I am supposed to rave my ass off if that makes sense.

Otherwise, cool track! Thanks for coming out!

pooo1 responds:

thanks for the critic

[Fistula]

I actually was surprised by how melodic and calming this is for a piece titled Fistula. I have no real critique beyond it is difficult to make out the kick and snare for the volume of the guitars. I wonder how this would sound if it were not for that.

BALDORF responds:

Yeah, the name was mostly just because I uploaded on Valentines Day and felt like giving it a nasty name lol

I'm not great with drum stuff or mixing/mastering, so that makes sense.

Thanks for the review!

[I'm So Happy I Could Die]

Definitely feeling the overstimulation!

I feel myself wanting more presence out of your kick and snare, and perhaps just a bit less reverb low end. I feel like the 250 hz and below of the wet signals are washing out the bass, as well as sub can probably come down a bit and bring up the top end of the bass.

The vocals could use more compression and volume to sit intelligibly.

Beyond that, I adore Miku, and I can MOSTLY understand her. What you've written sounds catchy.

Nice work!

3xBlast responds:

That's fantastic feedback!!! Rare to get such actionable insight on a track, very much appreciated!

[98]

I wish I could better understand this piece, as 9/8 is a very bold time signature and shows you are not afraid to be different. There are however some issues holding this piece back. For one, there are a lot of ideas going on at the same time and they do not really feel congruent to me, and there are some mixing problems, such as the hi hats are very prominent in my ears.

I certainly sense some direction in that the song is not the same all the way through and the melodies likewise swap to different instruments and themes. I feel like what this piece could use is a bit more space, some effects for your synths so they don't sound so dry, and more variation in percussion through sections -- as well as contrast in volume level. Most of all I feel like the last two are contributing to feelings of sameness.

I have no doubt however that in time you will master your ideal style of music though, and I wholeheartedly encourage you to keep going. There are tons of tutorials for the stuff I'm talking about here available on the internet for free, but there is no replacement for originality, which you have! Keep going, and thanks for coming out to NGADM!

toad-shroom responds:

I'm still getting the hang of the program I'm using (lmms) so I'm still figuring out how to do changes in dynamic. Thanks for the constructive criticism!